- Richard J. Bautch, Associate Dean and Associate Professor, School of Humanities, St. Edward's University
- Patrick Carey, Professor and William J. Kelly, S.J., Chair in Catholic Theology, Marquette University
- Kathleen Sprows Cummings, Concurrent Assistant Professor of History; Associate Director, Cushwa Center for the Study of American Catholicism, University of Notre Dame
- James P. McCartin, Assistant Professor of History and Associate Director, Center for Catholic Studies, Seton Hall University
- Tim Meagher, Committee Chair, Curator of American Catholic History and Professor of History, Catholic University
- James O'Toole, Professor and Clough Millenium Chair in History, Boston College
- Leslie Tentler, Ordinary Professor of History, Catholic University
- Emily Asch, St. Catherine University
- Matt Blessing, Marquette University
- John Buchtel, Georgetown University
- Alan Delozier, Seton Hall University
- Leon Hooper, S.J., Georgetown University
- Diane Maher, University of San Diego
- Maria Mazzenga, Catholic University
- Jean McManus, University of Notre Dame
- Robert K. O'Neill, Committee Chair, Boston College
- Kevin Cawley, University of Notre Dame
- Marta Deyrup, Seton Hall University
- Sharon Favaro, Seton Hall University
- Ann M. Hanlon, Marquette University
- Demian Katz, Villanova University
- Pat Lawton, CRRA
- Susan Leister, Georgetown University
- Thomas Leonhardt, Committee Chair, St. Edward's University
- Eric Lease Morgan, University of Notre Dame
- Steve Connaghan , Catholic University
- Artemis Kirk, Georgetown University
- Tom Leonhardt, St. Edward's University
- Tim Meagher, Catholic University
- Robert O'Neill, Boston College
- Ed Starkey, University of San Diego
- Thomas B. Wall, Boston College
- Janice Welburn, Marquette University
- Jennifer Younger, Board Chair, University of Notre Dame
- Charlotte Ames, University of Notre Dame
- Emily Asch, St. Catherine University
- Kathy Blackstead, University of Notre Dame
- Dustin Booher, Catholic University
- Amy Braitsch, Boston College
- John Buchtel, Georgetown University
- Theresa Byrd, University of San Diego
- Gay Dannelly, University of Notre Dame
- Paul Fisher, Seton Hall University
- Michael Foight, Villanova University
- Chrysanthy Grieco, Seton Hall University
- Kevin Gunn, Catholic University
- David Horn, Boston College
- Carol Johnson, St. Catherine University
- Maura Kenny, Seton Hall University
- Deborah Kloiber, St. Catherine University
- David Lacy, Villanova University
- Joseph Lucia, Villanova University
- Howard McGinn, Seton Hall University
- Chulin Meng, Loyola University Chicago
- Evelyn Minick, St. Joseph's University
- Elizabeth Myers, Loyola University Chicago
- Susan Ohmer, University of Notre Dame
- Alma Ortega, University of San Diego
- Jessica Pierce, Georgetown University
- Michele Plewa, Marquette University
- Darren Poley, Villanova University
- Robert Seal, Loyola University Chicago
- Denise Shorey, University of Notre Dame
- Stephen Spatz, Villanova University
- April Sullivan, St. Edward's University
- Kathy Young, Loyola University Chicago
- Jean Zanoni, Marquette University